One of the Walled Gardens' greatest strengths is that they've managed to collect… 🥁🥁
…their users' email addresses! 🤔

But why is an email address so strategic? 🎯

It's quite funny that in 2026, 37 years after the birth of the Web (counting from Tim Berners-Lee's 1989 proposal), we're still so interested in… users' email addresses. 🤭

But the reason is extremely simple: email is oil! 💰

Why is an email address strategically valuable in programmatic advertising?

An email address is a deterministic identifier when a person supplies it directly to a publisher or service and it is associated with their authenticated account. In suitable, authorised circumstances, it can act as a common reference for matching data that would otherwise live in separate technical environments.

For example, three uses make it attractive to publishers and AdTech companies:

  • 🔄 Connecting technologically incompatible environments: indirectly reconciling eligible data from a mobile browser environment (historically associated with third-party cookies) and connected TV (CTV), where device identifiers such as identifiers for advertising (IFAs) may be used. The email does not literally convert cookies into IFAs: matching requires a compatible identity solution and appropriate permissions.
  • ⬆️ Bridging media data and an advertiser's customer relationship management (CRM) data: for example, through a data clean room, where authorised partners can perform defined matching or analysis with access controls.
  • 📊 Enriching identity graphs: helping authorised identity solutions associate eligible signals with the same account or person rather than relying only on browser-level identifiers.

Think of it as an identity key, not a magic identifier that works automatically across every website, device or television. Matching rates, consent, interoperability and contractual arrangements still matter.

What exactly is a Login Wall—and how is it different from a paywall?

To collect email addresses, Walled Gardens have often made account creation central to the user experience. Publishers can use a similar mechanism: the Login Wall. 📧🧱

“Want to access the site? Sign up!” ✍️

“Don't want to sign up? Well, off you go!” 🚫

MechanismWhat the visitor must doWhat it changes
Login WallRegister or sign inCreates an authenticated relationship; not necessarily a paid subscription
PaywallPay or subscribeRestricts access based on payment, which may also require an account
Consent wallMake a choice about specific data processing or trackersRaises separate consent and privacy questions; registration is not consent

These approaches can coexist, but they should not be confused. France's CNIL explicitly discusses Login Walls alongside cookie walls and the trade-off between access to content and personal data.

Why haven't publishers put Login Walls everywhere already?

🎶 “If it were that easy, everyone would do it!” 🎶🤔

Until now, publishers have often been reluctant to introduce mandatory registration because it can significantly increase bounce rates, especially for non-branded SEO traffic and readers arriving through referral links.

You can understand users: having to create an account just to read one specific article is pretty annoying. 😤

The economic trade-off is straightforward: more information about the people who register, but potentially fewer people willing to continue reading. A publisher should therefore look at completed registrations, lost visits, engaged users and revenue—not just the number of emails collected.

Why could 2026 be a turning point for Login Walls?

🔄 Except that in 2026, the situation is changing for two reasons:

1. Zero Click Search is putting pressure on publisher referral traffic 😱

ChatGPT, Google's AI Overviews and other answer engines increasingly satisfy some information needs without a visit to the original source. My concern is that a large share of traditional search referrals could all but disappear for some kinds of content. (That is a warning about a possible direction, not a verified forecast for all publishers.)

A Pew Research Center analysis of US Google searches in March 2025 found that users clicked a traditional result on 8% of visits with an AI summary, versus 15% without one. (This is a US observational study of 900 adult participants, not a measurement of overall French publisher traffic loss.)

For more context, see our English analysis of what Zero Click Search means for the Open Web.

2. Apple's anti-tracking protections make cross-site identity harder 😱

Safari and WebKit have long limited third-party cookies and other cross-site tracking techniques. WebKit's tracking-prevention documentation details these restrictions. That makes logged-in first-party relationships more strategically interesting, even though a login does not bypass privacy rules.

The resulting audience attrition is also part of our work on how much publisher traffic can actually be activated through programmatic tools.

How can publishers create value from first-party email data?

For premium publishers in France and elsewhere, a registered relationship can support several uses—provided the data is collected and processed appropriately:

  • ✅ Enrich first-party data: connect content preferences, account interactions and other eligible publisher signals to authenticated users.
  • ✅ Connect first-party data across sites: where a common identifier and appropriate permissions allow it, use compatible ID solutions and server-side integrations to facilitate matching across properties.
  • ✅ Provide eligible audience signals to identity-graph providers: a potential data-monetisation avenue, subject to legal, technical and commercial constraints.

One important condition: just because an email is collected at registration doesn't mean the publisher can automatically use it for cross-site advertising or disclose it to third-party identity partners. Purpose, lawful basis, transparency and consent where required must be assessed separately. Hashing an email does not make it anonymous (see the CNIL's guidance on pseudonymised personal data).

Nor does every user need to be identified to make an Open Web campaign effective: cookieless supply and its activation challenges remain important alongside authenticated first-party data.

Is L'Équipe already an example of a Login Wall in France?

Some publishers have already crossed the Rubicon. One example I highlighted is Amaury Media and the L'Équipe app, where users have reported a requirement to create an account to continue using the service. (The precise access journey can vary by app version, feature and user.)

Public Google Play user reviews have described mandatory account creation in the L'Équipe app during 2026. That supports the observation of a registration gate, but does not establish how many users it affects, its conversion rate or its commercial results.

For the French market, this is a useful example of the tension between building an authenticated relationship and making it easy for casual readers to access content.

Will Login Walls become the norm for publishers in 2027?

That's my question—and perhaps the next big strategic debate in French programmatic advertising. 📧🧱

The economic incentive is obvious: publishers want to extract more value from non-subscriber sessions as traffic from search and the ability to follow people across the web come under pressure. But a forced login isn't automatically a winning business model.

If I were evaluating a Login Wall, I would focus on a handful of checks:

  1. Does registration deliver a real benefit to the reader? Offer a convincing reason to sign in—not just another form.
  2. How much readership is lost at the wall? Compare sign-up completion with bounce rate and retained audiences, especially for one-off SEO visitors.
  3. Does identification improve monetisation? Track eligible addressability and revenue per engaged user, not just email volume.
  4. Are the data uses understandable and lawful? Separate access to content from permissions for analytics, targeting or data sharing where needed.

What do you think? Will Login Walls become the norm among publishers in 2027 to keep extracting value from non-subscriber visits? Or will asking every visitor to register simply push some of them away? 🤔

Sources and further reading

Editorial note: the 2027 prediction, the commercial significance attributed to email and the prospective publisher strategy are GreyFox Ads' professional analysis. External sources document specific technical, regulatory and behavioural context; they do not establish that Login Walls will become universal.