Menu

← All articles

Programmatic: Saving the press... But who pays the bill???💸🤔

Programmatic: Saving the press... But who pays the bill???💸🤔

The financial situation is "complicated" for Open Web publishers:

😱 Advertising budgets shifting towards the Walled Gardens
😱 Zero-click AI answers threatening half of their traffic
😱 Subscriptions that aren't enough to fund every newsroom

Their appeal to the French government is understandable:

"Our journalists are an essential pillar of democracy. How can you help us?"

The problem is that:

  • Public finances aren't exactly in great shape 💸
  • It's tricky to introduce a new tax given the current public discontent😡

The solution proposed by the government?

Pass part of the bill on... to advertisers💡

That's the idea behind the proposed French bill on mandatory advertising spend allocation ("fléchage publicitaire").
👉 https://www.conseil-etat.fr/avis-consultatifs/derniers-avis-rendus/au-gouvernement/avis-sur-un-projet-de-loi-visant-a-renforcer-l-investissement-publicitaire-dans-les-services-de-presse-d-information-politique-et-generale

The short version: Advertisers spending more than €1 million a year on advertising will have to direct a share of their digital advertising spend towards the online political and general news press (the rate will be set by decree and capped at 10%).

EXCEPT THAT 👇

1️⃣ Should advertisers really be the ones footing the bill?🤔
Preserving high-quality journalism is an objective in the public interest.
But why should that objective create a purchasing obligation for certain companies? Especially if advertisers feel that the product being delivered doesn't meet their needs.
The French Conseil d'État (Council of State) considers the restriction on freedoms to be justified and proportionate, but that by no means settles the debate over whether it makes economic sense.

2️⃣ Which budgets will actually be reallocated?

Will advertisers cut their Google/Meta/Amazon budgets?

Or will they cut spending with other publishers and Broadcasters instead?😈
👉 Supporting the press at the expense of other French media... that would be a bit daft🤭

3️⃣ The programmatic minefield
Between the advertiser and the publisher: an agency, a DSP, an SSP, sometimes a curator…

Which amount will count towards meeting the obligation?

Gross spend? Spend excluding tech fees? The amount received by the publisher?
👉 Setting an obligation is one thing. Tracking where the euros go is another.

4️⃣ How do we distribute the revenue?

Advertisers seem to be free to choose which media outlets they want to invest in.
👉 So much for media pluralism...

5️⃣ The risk of circumvention
The Conseil d'État itself highlights the risk of firms getting around the obligation through foreign subsidiaries...

👉 What if it ends up penalising only domestic French advertisers?

6️⃣ We're ignoring the root of the problem
If advertisers are turning their backs on the Open Web's advertising offering, could it simply be because it no longer measures up to what the Walled Gardens have to offer?
👉 Shouldn't the number one priority be to make advertisers WANT to invest again? (https://www.open-garden.com/p/publicit-digitale-ce-qui-a-cass-l-open-web-et-comment-le-r-parer)

Original LinkedIn post: https://lnkd.in/p/e9nw9DnZ

Looking for a trusted programmatic partner?

Let’s discuss curation, media performance and transparency.

← Back to articles