Why are French publishers criticising programmatic curation?

On 2 September 2026, Journal du Net (JDN) published an investigation into curation as seen by French premium publishers.

And the least you can say is that publishers aren't happy: "Opacity, insufficient prices, high AdTech taxes. Publishers are demanding answers from platforms." (English rendering of the JDN article's opening summary.) ๐Ÿ˜ก

In a difficult economic climate, listening to publishers' grievances is essential for the ecosystem.

We can also add a few nuances to the complaints raised. Because the real story is a little more interesting than simply pointing at the Curators. ๐Ÿ‘€

First, what is curation? In programmatic advertising, a Curator packages selected inventory, audience or contextual signals and quality filters into a Curated Deal that a buyer can activate through a demand-side platform (DSP). A supply-side platform (SSP) is typically involved on the selling side. If the jargon still sounds like alphabet soup, here's my explanation of Curators and Curator seats.

Why do publishers consider programmatic curation opaque? ๐Ÿ˜ 

The opacity of Curation is not total. Through their SSP seats, publishers can, depending on their platforms and permissions:

  • ๐Ÿ”Ž Check who the Curator Vendors are, their spend and their cost-per-mille prices (CPMs).
  • ๐Ÿšซ Block specific Curator Vendors.

The opacity mainly concerns the difference between:

  • The CPM at which the publisher sells in its ad server ๐Ÿ’ต
  • The CPM paid by the Trader in their DSP ๐Ÿ’ต๐Ÿ’ต

Those two numbers are not automatically the same. And the difference is not automatically the Curator Vendor's profit: several separate technology or service costs may be involved (visibility depends on the contracts, SSP seat and reporting access).

Where do the fees in a Curated Deal go?

There can be several layers of fees in a Curated Deal. Here are the four places to look before concluding that the whole difference between the selling CPM and the buyer CPM is a Curator's margin.

Possible components of a Curated Deal, not a universal fee schedule
LayerWhat it representsThe transparency question
1. Publisher sale / SSPThe SSP selling-price CPM and, where relevant, SSP fees. The sale price may be visible to the publisher if it owns the SSP seat; the picture can be less clear when a Reseller owns the seat.Who is the actual seller, and what reaches the publisher?
2. Curation platformThe platform's commission or service fees. Examples of curation technology providers include Equativ, PubMatic, Magnite, Xandr, Criteo, Index Exchange, FreeWheel and TripleLift (actual models and fees differ).What technical services does the platform provide, and at what cost?
3. Curator VendorThe Curator Vendor's margin for designing, packaging, managing or optimising the deal.What incremental benefit does the buyer receive for that remuneration?
4. Paid marketplace filtersAdditional data, semantic, brand safety and ID targeting or verification services.Which filters are actually activated, and are their charges disclosed?

These are possible categories, not four mandatory fees on every transaction. Some services are bundled and some are absent; DSP buying fees may also apply outside this breakdown. The SSP selling price itself is a transaction value, not an additional commission.

So the real underlying question is:

"As a buyer, how much transparency does the Curator Vendor give me about how these costs are split?"

And above all: "Are ALL THESE layers of fees JUSTIFIED?"

There is a real reason to ask. In a separate JDN report on a reconciliation test, the total gap measured in certain curated buying setups approached 75%. That figure came from one specific advertiser/publisher test with several configurations, not a representative industry average โ€” and it must not be treated as the standard Curator commission.

Why are publisher CPMs under pressure?

Prices that are too low for publishers are the second big complaint. This is the whole question of "how value is shared across the programmatic supply chain".

The publisher supplies the raw material (inventory).
It's the rock on which the ecosystem is built.
It must be properly remunerated.

And it's equally logical that every intermediary that ADDS Value should be paid in proportion to its contribution (e.g. a retailer bringing its Retail Data deserves the lion's share).

That contribution might mean genuinely incremental buyers, useful retail data, better inventory selection, robust verification or easier activation โ€” not merely adding another invoice to the chain.

So the underlying question is the same: whether the various fees are justified. Low publisher CPMs alone cannot tell us whether curation creates or destroys value; we also need to see who gets paid, for what, and how the deal performs.

Example: where could an โ‚ฌ8 buyer CPM go?

Imagine a Media Trader paying โ‚ฌ8 CPM for a Curated Deal in their DSP. Here is a deliberately simplified, fictional illustration of how that โ‚ฌ8 might be split:

Hypothetical CPM allocation โ€” not live GreyFox Ads pricing or a market benchmark
Recipient or cost categoryAmount per 1,000 impressions
Publisher's net revenueโ‚ฌ4.40
Sell-side SSP chargesโ‚ฌ0.60
Curation platformโ‚ฌ0.80
Curator Vendorโ‚ฌ1.20
Data, semantic, safety and ID servicesโ‚ฌ1.00
Total buyer CPMโ‚ฌ8.00

Methodology: all amounts are invented for teaching purposes and add up to โ‚ฌ8.00. They are not GreyFox Ads' fee structure, a measured campaign or a market average. DSP fees, if separately charged, are excluded here; actual contract structures, overlaps and price definitions vary.

The point? Without buyer-to-publisher reconciliation and a clear cost breakdown, no one can reliably attribute the difference to a single intermediary. And a lower cost is not necessarily better value if it also reduces quality, reach or outcomes.

How can programmatic curation become more transparent?

There is no need to condemn the whole technology. What matters is whether both sides of the market can actually understand the economics of a Curated Deal. My practical checklist:

  1. Identify the real seller. Know whether inventory comes from a publisher-owned SSP seat or a Reseller and favour direct supply paths where appropriate.
  2. Break down the fees. Distinguish platform fees, Curator Vendor remuneration and paid targeting or verification services without double-counting.
  3. Show the value delivered. Assess what each layer adds: incremental reach, better brand suitability, attention, video completion or operational simplicity (depending on the campaign objectives).
  4. Give buyers a readable supply path. Document which inventory is eligible, which sites are excluded and which services are enabled, subject to platform reporting capabilities.
  5. Keep publishers in the conversation. Discuss the CPM they actually receive and whether the commercial terms create sustainable value for their inventory.

This is also where Supply Path Optimisation (SPO) and the problem of excessive Reseller paths enter the picture.

Can curation still create value for publishers and advertisers?

Absolutely โ€” if the value is real, not just another margin. Curation is an extremely powerful tool for building advertising propositions and making audiences flow more freely across the Open Web.

The risk of attacking Curation without nuance is:

  1. Undermining one of the Open Web's few growth drivers... ๐Ÿ’ธ
  2. Encouraging Curator Vendors to go and build their propositions elsewhere instead, with the Walled Gardens for example... ๐Ÿ˜ˆ

We can already see a more constructive alternative: some publishers are opening their own Curator seats to expand audiences, enrich inventory and retain greater control of their commercial proposition.

The choice isn't simply for or against curation. It's between curation that obscures who gets what, and curation that actually helps advertisers spend better while fairly remunerating publishers.

GreyFox Ads' perspective: transparency should be the standard

GreyFox Ads is an advertising sales house built 100% around Curation. It's what allows us to create our Master Deals, with maximum transparency for the buyer.

Based here in France, we build a single Curated Deal combining selected Open Web inventory, targeting, quality checks and a readable cost structure. We also provide hands-on programmatic and curation consulting.

Our conviction is simple: Curators should be paid for the value they create, not for the opacity of the system.

Want to know more? ๐Ÿ“ง Contact GreyFox Ads.

Sources & further reading

This article expresses an independent interpretation of publishers' criticism, grounded in the cited reports and the author's experience of the French programmatic market. Contracts, fee structures and reporting permissions vary across companies.